If you’re planning a deck building project, this question usually hits somewhere between picking railing styles and arguing about board color: PVC or composite? And honestly, it’s a fair debate. Both are popular. Both promise low maintenance. Both look great in photos. But they don’t behave the same once Midwest weather gets involved.
I’ve helped homeowners all over the area make this call, and it’s rarely about which material is “better.” It’s about which one fits your outdoor living experience, your budget, and how much time you want to spend maintaining your outdoor space.
Let’s slow it down and talk through it like real people who’ve actually walked on these decks.
The Core Difference Between PVC and Composite Decking
At the most basic level:
- PVC decking is made entirely from synthetic materials
- Composite decking blends recycled plastics with wood fibers
That difference matters more than most homeowners realize. Composite deck still behave a bit like wood because, well, they contain wood. PVC doesn’t. That impacts durability, temperature, weight, and even how the deck feels under your feet.
Both options are common in modern deck building services, especially for homeowners who want something unlike wood decks without giving up style.
Composite Decking: Pros, Cons & Best Uses
Composite deck have become a go-to choice for many custom deck contractors, especially when homeowners want a balance between performance and cost.
Pros of Composite Decking
- Looks closer to natural wood than PVC
- Offers excellent long term durability compared to traditional wood decks
- Lower maintenance than wood decks no staining or sealing
- Works well with custom deck design, including multi level decks and outdoor structures
- Holds color well and resists fading better than natural wood
Cons of Composite Decking
- Can retain heat in direct sun
- Heavier than PVC, which matters for certain deck installation scenarios
- Not completely waterproof moisture can still affect the wood fibers over time
Composite materials are often ideal for homeowners who love the warmth of wood but don’t want the upkeep. For many backyard projects, it’s the sweet spot between appearance and performance.
PVC Decking: Pros, Cons & Best Uses
PVC decking is often chosen when performance is the top priority especially in areas exposed to moisture.
Pros of PVC Decking
- Fully synthetic, so water resistance is excellent
- Extremely low maintenance
- Lightweight compared to composite
- Strong resistance to mold, mildew, and insects
- Great for decks near water features, patios, or shaded areas
Cons of PVC Decking
- Higher upfront cost
- Can feel less “wood-like” underfoot
- May expand and contract more with temperature swings
PVC shines when homeowners want durability without compromise. It’s a popular option for clients who never want to think about deck repair again or at least not for a very long time.
Cost Comparison: PVC vs Composite Decking
Let’s talk numbers without pretending pricing is ever perfectly fixed.
- Composite decking generally costs less than PVC upfront
- PVC decking sits at the higher end due to material performance and lifespan
Installation services for both are similar, but PVC can sometimes require more precise spacing due to expansion. Over time, many homeowners find PVC’s higher price offsets future maintenance savings, especially in harsh climates.
If budget is your top priority, composite often wins. If longevity and moisture resistance matter most, PVC starts to make more sense.
Which One Is Right for Your Outdoor Living Space?
Here’s the part no brochure tells you: the “best” decking material depends on how you actually use your outdoor living area.
If you picture family dinners, kids running barefoot, and a space that feels warm and familiar, composite decks often feel right. If you want a worry-free surface that handles water, snow, and humidity without blinking, PVC is hard to beat.
Both options can support beautiful deck ideas fire pits, pergolas, outdoor kitchens, and personalized designs that bring your vision to life. The key is choosing materials that align with your lifestyle, not just trends.
A Contractor’s Honest Take
I’ve built decks with wood, composite, and PVC. Each has its place. The mistake happens when homeowners are sold on features they don’t need or scared away from options that would actually serve them better.
That’s why we focus on free consultations. Not sales pitches. Just real conversations about how you live, how you use your space, and what will still make sense five, ten, fifteen years from now.
Ready to Choose the Right Deck Material & Contractor?
If you’re planning deck building in Westfield, IN, or want help sorting through composite vs PVC options for your backyard, reach out for a free estimate. We’ll walk you through the pros, cons, and costs clearly, honestly, and without pressure.